| 2025 |
| Waldy Reyes- Campbellsville University (NAIA) |
| Caleb Bean- St. Marys College of Maryland (D3) |
| Bryson Hutzell- Charleston university (D2) |
| Henry Itani - Bethany Lutheran College (D3) |
| Rayden Deets - Bethany Lutheran College (D3) |
| Yunior Pena - Bethany Lutheran College (D3) |
| Jared Harry - Bethany Lutheran College (D3) |
| Dorian Arraiz - Kansas Christian College (NCCAA) |
| Tyree Claxton - Freed-Hardeman University (NAIA) |
| 2024 |
| Alejandro Bonilla- Georgian Court (D2) |
| Cody Cox- SMC (NAIA) |
| Jaden Hendricks- University of Ft. Lauderdale (NCCAA) |
| Jordan Thomas- Eastern Connecticut University (D3) |
| Justin Rosa-Pinero- Penn State Greater Allegheny (D3) |
| 2023 |
| Andrew Leginze- Salem University (D2) |
| Drew Colaizzi- Washington Jefferson (D3) |
| Hunter Rose- Salem University (D2) |
| Josh Edwards- York College of Pennsylvania (D3) |
| Justin Aponte- Middle Georgia State (NAIA) |
| Kendall White- Claflin University (D2) |
| Layne Freese- Salem University (D2) |
| Luis Calvo- Salem University (D2) |
| Nick Norton – Christopher-Newport (D3) |
| Roy Tayman- University of South Carolina Beaufort (D2) |
| Ryan Tayman- University of South Carolina Beaufort (D2) |
| Tariq Johnson- Wilson College (D3) |
| Travis Bradley- Neumann University (D3) |
| 2022 |
| Mikey Guy- Frostburg (D2) |
| Francis Segarra- Queens- NY (D2) |
| Eli Wilhelm- Fort Lauderdale (NCCAA) |
| Brandon Pellitier- Fort Lauderdale (NCCAA) |
| Preston Long- Fort Lauderdale (NCCAA) |
| Jordan McKenzie- Wilson College (D3) |
| Jesus Moscat- Lesley (D3) |
| 2018 |
| Derek Taitano- St. Mary's College (D3) |
| Gavin Moore- Mary Washington (D3) |
| 2017 |
| Travis Brashear- Frostburg (D2) |
| 2016 |
| Christian Rice- Shenandoah (D3) |
| Ian Schweppe- Roanoke (D3) |
